If you didn't know who Alan Milburn was this time last year, you certainly will do now. The Milburn review into young people and work has been hard to miss in the headlines.
But now the final report has been published, what does it actually say about young people, health and participation – and what could it mean for the services supporting them?
The report is expansive - exploring different aspects of the system, from the labour market, to education, health, welfare and the changes needed for a whole system overhaul. This summary focuses on just a snapshot.
What has the review found?
- The whole system is failing young people. 13.5% of 16- to 24-year-olds are currently not in employment, education or training. Without action, this could rise to 16.3% by 2031.
- Young people want opportunities to participate. More than 8 in 10 young people (84%) not in employment, education or training actively want a job, education or training.
- Health is a major barrier. Nearly three in ten (28.4 per cent) report disability or ill health as the primary reason for not being in education, training or employment, with poor health a secondary factor for many more.
- The health system is not doing enough. ICBs spent just 1.04 per cent of their total spend on young people’s mental health, with most funding going towards treating severe problems later, rather than when difficulties first begin to affect a young person’s life.
It is clear that young people have been let down for too long and the journey into adulthood is tougher than ever. As one disabled young person told the review: "You don't jump into water without knowing how to swim, but with adulthood, people expect you to."
What about the recommendations?
- A Youth Opportunity Service in every area by 2029, responsible for giving young people outside education a route back into participation – commissioned strategic authorities and building on existing services. Young people would meet a named adviser within 14 days and agree a participation plan within four weeks. The service would join up employment, careers, participation, health and practical support around the young people.
- New statutory Opportunity and Support Guarantees. The Opportunity Guarantee is a route into a job, an apprenticeship, a college place, a work placement, civic service or starting a business. The Support Guarantee is the health, employment and practical help needed to take it.
- Early support hubs should be expanded: to at least one in every upper-tier local authority in England over this Parliament, with expansion starting in 2027.
- A bigger role for health services: ICBs would have new responsibilities to work with strategic authorities and local agencies to improve youth participation, including sufficiently funding and commissioning the health services needed locally. It also calls for earlier, needs led mental health support and national maximum waiting-time standards for young people's mental health care by 2028.
- Devolution and longer-term funding: Multi-year Participation Agreements would bring together funding, powers and accountability, giving strategic authorities greater responsibility for coordinating local provision. Delivery should build on existing services, commissioning additional capacity where needed and funding should be multi-year.
The review also proposes an initial £500m investment in 2027/28 to kickstart reform, including enhanced employment and mental health support.
It also spotlights Youth Access member Centre33 Cambridgeshire and Peterborough as one of two case studies, whose work demonstrates the multiple challenges experienced by young people not in employment, education or training who experience higher levels of emotional distress alongside practical needs such as housing insecurity and food and fuel poverty.
There is much to welcome in the review, but also some areas that require attention.
Three things to get right
1. Welfare reform must remove barriers to work, not create them
The proposals include abolishing the Universal Credit health element and Personal Independent Payment (PIP) under 25s, and replacing them with alternatives equating to £3.6 billion of cuts to support for young disabled people. This is a significant concern. Financial security is fundamental to mental health and participation, and the Fonagy review highlighted key evidence linking falling income to worsening mental health. In any case PIP is not an unemployment benefit. It helps disabled people meet the additional costs of everyday life whether in or out of work.
Reducing income makes the barriers the review wants to address even harder to overcome. As Joseph Rowntree Foundation (JRF) puts it - the wider support offer won’t succeed if the young people it is meant to help are also struggling to afford food or the bus to college. Young people already receive lower benefit rates despite facing many of the same living costs as older adults – food, travel, rent, energy bills. Social security policy too often assumes young people can rely on family support as a safety net – overlooking the reality for many who cannot.
When Milburn says these changes won’t be easy or “pain free”, we ask: who is at the receiving end of this pain? Too often it is people who are disabled, young and poor.
2. Digital support should expand choice, not narrow it
Digital is threaded throughout the recommendations, from signposting and online resources to AI tools and practitioner-led interventions - including a 'digital first' approach to support. Digital can improve access and offer a flexible route into support. But the system must offer genuine choice, trusted relationships and human care at the earliest opportunity. Channelling young people down narrowly prescribed digital pathways risks excluding those who need a different kind of help.
3. Young people's voices must shape implementation and delivery
45% of young people not in employment, education or training who contributed to the review considered young people with lived experience the most credible source of solutions. That needs to translate into meaningful involvement in designing, commissioning, delivering and evaluating local provision.
What happens next?
Coming shortly after the Fonagy review into the Prevalence of mental health conditions, ADHD and Autism, Milburn reinforces the importance of addressing young people's mental health and wider circumstances together.
Both reviews make the case for expanding early support hubs into every local authority area. This would help the government deliver its manifesto commitment to open-access mental health support in every community, tackle the wider barriers that keep young people out of work, education and training, and build a more preventative, needs-led system alongside the NHS.
The Government now has a clear responsibility to act, and time is not on our side. Funding for the 24 existing early support hubs is due to end in March 2027. Leaving established services scale down, only to rebuild later, risks wasting valuable expertise and resources.
With the Mental Health Strategy due before Christmas, it is essential that the Government takes this opportunity to set out the funding, accountability and implementation support needed to deliver early support hubs in every local area.
Youth Access will keep working with members and partners to push for this ambition.